Click for Info 

Title:
ISO: Soft Peanut Butter Cookie
Board:
From:
Kar 7-11-1998
 MSG ID: 0024679

I'm looking for a VERY soft peanut butter cookie recipe. My mother used to make a peanut butter cookie called "Tom Thumb" cookies. The cookies were rolled in a ball, a thumb print was put in them and they baked with an indentation in them. When they were served, jelly was put in the indentation--kind of like a peanut butter and jelly cookie. They were VERY good. The cookies were not criss-crossed with a fork like many peanut butter cookies and they were tender, not crispy. The recipe came from the Parade Magazine (the one that comes in the Sunday newspapers) and appeared about 35 - 40 years ago. I sure hope that someone can help me--my family has lost the recipe and I haven't found one like it in my cookbooks. Thank you!!!!!


Replies:
ISO: Soft Peanut Butter Cookie
  Kar - 7-11-1998
 
MSG ID: 0024679
  1 Recipe(tried): Soft Peanut Butter Cookie
    Mary - 7-11-1998
   
MSG ID: 0024684
  2 Recipe: Thumbprint Cookies
    Brooke - 7-11-1998
   
MSG ID: 0024688
  3 Recipes from Jif.......read on...
    Terri/GA - 7-11-1998
   
MSG ID: 0024693
  4 Re: Recipes from Jif.......read on...and one more....
    Terri/GA - 7-11-1998
   
MSG ID: 0024694
  5 Recipe(tried): Re: Recipes from Jif.......read on...
    Dawn ~ in CO ~ - 7-11-1998
   
MSG ID: 0024716
  6 Re: ISO--Soft Peanut Butter Cookie
    gramaj - 7-12-1998
   
MSG ID: 0024765
  7 Re: Recipes from Jif.......read on...
    Dix - 7-14-1998
   
MSG ID: 0024918
  8 Re: Recipes from Jif.......read on...Nope never lived in TN. (nt)
    Dawn ~ in CO ~ - 7-15-1998
   
MSG ID: 0025069
  9 Re: Dix
    Dawn ~ in CO ~ - 7-15-1998
   
MSG ID: 0025083
  10 ISO: Jif Peanut Butter Buckeye Balls
    Penny in Raleigh - 12-20-2005
   
MSG ID: 0075231
  11 Recipe: Jif Buckeye balls
    Mike Illinois - 2-4-2006
   
MSG ID: 0075748
  12 Recipe(tried): Thumbprint Cookies - recipe review
    Halyna - NY - 10-14-2007
   
MSG ID: 0082092
  13 Thanks so much for the recipe review Halyna! (nt)
    Betsy at Recipelink.com - 10-14-2007
   
MSG ID: 0082094
Search: 
Keywords: 
In Association with Amazon.com

Amazon Shopping:


The Everything Vegetarian Cookbook

Featured in Cookbook Heaven 

Copyright 1995 - 2008  The Kitchen Link,Inc.
All Rights Reserved - www.recipelink.com - Privacy
2008