We are regulars at 54th Street. We were told the same ingredients. I have gotten close, but not perfect yet. It's not the ingredients giving me trouble, it's the proportions. Pointer: Last week I neded something quick to take to a party. I took a small crock pot (1 qt) into the store and asked them to "Gringo Me." While I sat there and drank my beer they took the crock pot, filled it with dip and brought out four boxes of chips to go with it. They charged me for three orders of the appetizer version. Couldn't have done it myself any easier or cheaper!