Recipe: Scotch Pie, Scotch Pie (Mutton Pie) and Irish Mutton Pie recipe

SCOTCH PIE
Granny Black's, Candleriggs, Glasgow
Source: Traditional Scotch Recipes

Large numbers of Scotch Pies are sold in Scotland every day - they are an original "fast food" and are often sold at the half-time interval at football (soccer) matches. The pies are made in special straight-sided moulds, roughly 3-31/2 inches (7.5-8.5cm) in diameter and about 11/2 inches (4cm) deep. A pastry lid, inside the pie, covers the meat about 1/2 inch (1cm) below the rim. This leaves a space at the top of the pie which can be filled, if required - with hot gravy, baked beans, mashed (creamed) potatoes etc. The meat is usually mutton (sometimes of varying quality). Many bakers have their own recipes and add spices to give additional flavour - there is now an annual competition for the best Scotch Pie.

Grannie Black, in Candleriggs in Glasgow, was a character who had such a reputation for such good mutton pies that people came from far and wide - the pub named after her (pictured here) has, unfortunately, been demolished.

The quantities below should make roughly 8/10 pies.

INGREDIENTS FOR THE MEAT FILLING:
1 pound (500g or two cups) lean lamb, minced (ground)
Pinch of mace or nutmeg
Salt and pepper
Quarter pint (150ml) gravy
INGREDIENTS FOR THE HOT WATER PASTRY:
1 pound (500g or four cups) plain flour
6 ounces (175g or 3/4 cup) lard
6 fluid ounces (225ml or 3/4 cup) approximately of water
Pinch of salt
Milk for glazing

You will also need glasses or jars, approximately 3-31/2 inches (7.5-8.5cm) in diameter to shape the pie.

Create the filling by mixing the minced (ground) lamb, spice and seasoning.

Make the pastry by sifting the flour and salt into a warm bowl. Make a well in the centre of the flour. Melt the lard in a scant measure of water and, when it is bubbling, add to the flour and mix thoroughly. Take a small amount (remember the mixture should make 8/10 pies, with their tops) and form into a ball and keep the rest warm while making each pastry case. This is done by rolling a suitable amount for each pie and shaping the crust round the base of a glass or jar approximately 3-31/2 inches (7.5-8.5cm) in diameter. Make sure there are no cracks in the pastry - you can trim round the top of the case to make it even. As the pastry cools and gets cool, remove the glass and continue until you have about a quarter of the pastry left to make the lids.

Fill the cases with the meat and add the gravy to make the meat moist.

Roll the remaining pastry and use the glass to cut the lids. Wet the edges of the lids, place over the meat and press down lightly over the filling. Pinch the edges and trim. Cut a small hole or vent in the centre of the lid (to allow the steam to escape).

Glaze with milk and bake for about 45 minutes at 275F/140C/Gas mark 1. If the pies are not eaten immediately, they can be stored in the 'fridge but always ensure they are properly reheated before being eaten.

---

SCOTCH PIES (MUTTON PIES)
Source: The British Food Trust
Serves 4

These pies are traditional to all parts of Scotland and have been praised by many eminent people, including Dr. Johnson, who was not known for his kindly remarks.

They are usually made with hot-water pastry crust but shortcrust can also be used. if using shortcrust pastry, use 225g (8 oz) fat to 450g (1 lb) flour and bake at 200 C / 400 F / Gas 6 for 15 minutes. Pork can also be used.

PASTRY:
Lard - 110g (4 oz), or dripping or butter
Hot water - 300 ml (1/2 pint)
Plain flour - 450g (1 lb)
Salt
Milk - a little, to glaze
FILLING:
Lean minced lamb - 450g (1 lb), free from fat, bone or gristle
Onion - 1 small, finely chopped
Ground mace or nutmeg - pinch
Worcestershire sauce - dash
Salt and pepper
Stock or gravy - 4 tbsp

Prepare the meat and onion, then add the spice and Worcestershire sauce, season it well and reserve. To make the pastry all the ingredients and the room should be warm.

Put the fat and water into a saucepan and bring to the boil. Sift the flour and salt into a basin, make a well in the centre and pour the hot liquid into this and mix quickly with a spatula until cool enough to handle, then form into a ball. This must be done quickly before the fat hardens.

Put on to a floured surface and pat flat. Divide it in four and keep the rest warm, then roll out three-quarters into a circle, putting a small jar about 7.5 cm (3 inches) across in the middle.

Mould the pastry around the jar and when it stands well remove the jar and do the three others the same way. Roll out the remaining pastry and cut out the lids.

Fill up the pastry cases with the meat mixture and add a little gravy or stock to each pie. Dampen the edges and put the lids on, making a small slit in the centre of each and brushing the top and sides with
a little milk.

Bake on a baking sheet at 130 C / 250 F / Gas 1/2 for about 45 minutes.

---

IRISH MUTTON PIE
Source: CookItSimply

FOR THE PASTRY:
3/4 cup (100 g) 4 oz flour
1/4 teaspoon baking powder
4 - 5 tablespoons water
FOR THE FLAVOURING:
200 g (8 oz) lean mutton
1 onion
a few sticks of celery
1 pint (600 ml) stock
2 oz (50 g) suet
large pinch of salt
6 large potatoes, sliced
3 carrots
1 large turnip
salt and pepper

Cut the meat into cubes and put them into a casserole with the stock.

Clean, prepare and slice the carrots, onion, turnip and celery and add them to the pan with the seasoning. Simmer for 1 hour.

Add the potatoes and boil for a further 15 minutes.

Make the pastry by combining the flour, grated suet, salt and baking powder with the water to make a dough. Roll out the pastry and cover the top of the stew with it.

Put the lid on the casserole and simmer for half an hour until the pastry is done. Serve in the pan.