Hi! I really LOVE to have my cookies be soft, so here are my tricks:
1. Instead of two sticks of margarine, I use one stick of butter and one stick of FLEISCHMAN'S BRAND margarine. Other margarines do NOT cook as well.
2. Buy a baking STONE. These bake the best cookies I have ever tasted! (and I HAVE tried other baking sheets, etc. that claimed to bake "evenly" -- withOUT success). The first batch of cookies made each time the stone is heated will probably need to be cooked a couple of minutes longer than the rest, but otherwise it's the same as metal for time, etc. The ridges of the cookies ARE as soft as the middle, most of the time.
ABOUT BAKING STONES: Note that you do NOT have to grease the stone EVER, as the cookies will never stick; over time, the grease from your baking will bake into the stone and change its color, but will NOT affect taste. Do not use soap to wash it, only hot water. Also, be CAREFUL! The stone stays hot for quite some time after coming out of the oven. Let it air-cool before washing it, or you can crack it.
3. Use an Ice Cream scoop (preferably very small, with a mechanical release) to make the cookies about the same size. This makes for more even cooking, also.
4. Let the cookies cool on the stone for 2-3 minutes (NO MORE!), then IMMEDIATELY put them on paper plates, single stack. Put the Paper plates inside gallon-size Ziploc bags RIGHT AWAY. This keeps them fresh and soft for up to three days. Suprisingly, the paper only absorbs the grease, and does NOT dry out to cookies.
5. Enjoy!
Anne
1. Instead of two sticks of margarine, I use one stick of butter and one stick of FLEISCHMAN'S BRAND margarine. Other margarines do NOT cook as well.
2. Buy a baking STONE. These bake the best cookies I have ever tasted! (and I HAVE tried other baking sheets, etc. that claimed to bake "evenly" -- withOUT success). The first batch of cookies made each time the stone is heated will probably need to be cooked a couple of minutes longer than the rest, but otherwise it's the same as metal for time, etc. The ridges of the cookies ARE as soft as the middle, most of the time.
ABOUT BAKING STONES: Note that you do NOT have to grease the stone EVER, as the cookies will never stick; over time, the grease from your baking will bake into the stone and change its color, but will NOT affect taste. Do not use soap to wash it, only hot water. Also, be CAREFUL! The stone stays hot for quite some time after coming out of the oven. Let it air-cool before washing it, or you can crack it.
3. Use an Ice Cream scoop (preferably very small, with a mechanical release) to make the cookies about the same size. This makes for more even cooking, also.
4. Let the cookies cool on the stone for 2-3 minutes (NO MORE!), then IMMEDIATELY put them on paper plates, single stack. Put the Paper plates inside gallon-size Ziploc bags RIGHT AWAY. This keeps them fresh and soft for up to three days. Suprisingly, the paper only absorbs the grease, and does NOT dry out to cookies.
5. Enjoy!
Anne
MsgID: 0218439
Shared by: Anne in Aurora, Illinois
In reply to: ISO: Softer cookies and preventing a cake fro...
Board: All Baking at Recipelink.com
Shared by: Anne in Aurora, Illinois
In reply to: ISO: Softer cookies and preventing a cake fro...
Board: All Baking at Recipelink.com
- Read Replies (5)
- Post Reply
- Post New
- Save to Recipe Box
Reviews and Replies: | |
1 | ISO: Softer cookies and preventing a cake from flattening |
Spring in Texas | |
2 | RE: Soft cookies & flat cakes |
Cathy in Colorado | |
3 | Recipe(tried): Softer Cookies |
Anne in Aurora, Illinois | |
4 | ISO: Baking stone |
Spring in Texas | |
5 | ISO: Flat Cake - Still need help |
Spring in Texas | |
6 | RE: Cake recipe |
Cathy in Colorado |
ADVERTISEMENT
Random Recipes from:
Desserts - Cookies, Brownies, Bars
Desserts - Cookies, Brownies, Bars
- Three Smore Cookie Recipes
- Traditional Italian Pizzelles with 5 Variations
- Chewy Dried Fruit Bars
- Homemade Girl Scout Thin Mint Cookies (copycat, scratch recipe)
- Yule Log Cookies
- Chocolate Mint Snow-Top Cookies
- Dutch Almond Cookies
- Toffee Malted Cookies
- Raisin Sugar Cookies, Seventeen Cookbook, 1964
- Pumpkin Nut Bars with Orange Icing
UPLOAD AN IMAGE
Allowed file types: .gif .png .jpg .jpeg
Allowed file types: .gif .png .jpg .jpeg
POST A REPLY
Post a Request - Answer a Question
Share a Recipe
Thank You To All Who Contribute
Post a Request - Answer a Question
Share a Recipe
Thank You To All Who Contribute
POST A NEW MESSAGE
Post a Request - Answer a Question
Share a Recipe
Thank You To All Who Contribute
Post a Request - Answer a Question
Share a Recipe
Thank You To All Who Contribute