Okay...my turn:

Last year I gave out glow-in-the-dark toothbrushes (in individual, sealed boxes) with little boxes of toothpaste taped to them. Mixed reactions. ;0)

One year, a group of Moms decorated a big box to look like an aquarium. We put it on a table and handed the kids a cane pole with a string attached at the end. On the end of the string was a clothespin. The kids had to line up a few feet from the table.

The kids would then have to "fish" for their treats. They would lower the "bait" into the "water" and the moms hiding in the back would attach a little bag filled with treats (and Scripture verses) to the clothespin. We got REAL carried away and started tugging on the line before letting go. The kids would pull reeeeeal hard until we would finally let go. Needless to say, that clothespin and bag would fly backwards and konk some unsuspecting soul in the head. It was FUN!!! Shame on us! ;0) (LOL)