ADVERTISEMENT
- Real Recipes from Real People -

Wendy - re: butter vs margarine in cookie recipe

Misc.
Wendy - don't know the technical explanation for it, but especially with cookies, there can be a big difference in the way cookies turn out when you use butter vs. margarine. And never ever use a tub margarine for baking - always choose a good quality stick margarine.

Butter seems to change the consistancy and appearance and the way cookies expand or raise - don't know why. I've used both, and have to say that in this particular recipe, margarine works better. But try it both ways - you can always eat the "failures"~~ I always give DH the "slightly" burned ones, so he's my quality-control checker!! He likes that job -

I also know there is a big difference in regular old chocolate chip cookies when using butter vs. margarine. Perhaps some of the more knowledgeable bakers out there will have a reason - probably due to the lower melting point of butter, or something like that.
MsgID: 0220714
Shared by: june/FL
In reply to: Thank You: That Molasses Cookie Recipe looks amazin...
Board: All Baking at Recipelink.com
  • Read Replies (16)
  • Post Reply
  • Post New
  • Save to Recipe Box
ADVERTISEMENT
Random Recipes
  • Stir-Fried Indonesian Chicken
  • STIR-FRIED INDONESIAN CHICKEN 1 teaspoon plus 1 tablespoon vegetable oil, divided use 1 green onion, thinly sliced 1 garlic clove, minced 1 medium lime* 1 medium orange* 2 tablespoons soy sauce 1 tablespoon honey 1/2 ...
  • On the Border Queso
  • All it is is Land O Lakes American cheese and Rotel. Mix with peppers, tomatoes, white pepper and pico di gallo (onions, tomatoes and cilantro). I work at on the...
  • Grama's Popcorn Balls
  • This is from an old Mennonite cookbook (Oklahoma) and this is the way popcorn balls used to be made. GRAMA'S POPCORN BALLS 1 cups sugar 1/2 Tablespoon vinegar (1 1/2 teaspoons) 4 quarts (16 cups) popped corn, well sa...
  • Double Chocolate Rocky Road Bars
  • DOUBLE CHOCOLATE ROCKY ROAD BARS 1 1/2 cups graham cracker crumbs 1/2 cup butter, softened 1 1/2 cups coconut 1 1/2 cups nuts, chopped 1 1/2 cups miniature marshmallows 1 cup semisweet chocolate chips 1 cup sweetened ...
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Chicken Picadillo-Stuffed Poblanos
  • CHICKEN PICADILLO-STUFFED POBLANOS 4 large poblano chili peppers, halved lengthwise, stemmed and seeded 2 tablespoons extra-virgin olive oil 1 medium onion, chopped (about 3/4 cup) 1 yellow bell pepper, chopped (1 to ...
  • Crumb Coffeecake
  • Hi Pat:-) This is a wonderful recipe from The King Arthur Flour Baker's Companion. I hope you enjoy it, and that it is what you are looking for. CRUMB COFFEECAKE Yield: sixteen 2-inch wedges, twenty-four 2-inch square...
UPLOAD AN IMAGE
Allowed file types: .gif .png .jpg .jpeg

POST A REPLY
Post a Request - Answer a Question
Share a Recipe
Thank You To All Who Contribute
  • Wendy - re: butter vs margarine in cookie recipe
  • Please select one:
  • This message includes a recipe that I have not made Recipe: will appear as the first word of the title
  • This message includes a recipe that I have made Recipe (tried): will appear as the first words of the title
  • This message is a question or a request for a recipe ISO: (In Search of) will appear as the first words of the title
  • This message is to thank the person(s) that answered my request Thank You will appear as the first words of the title
  • No Prefix


POST A NEW MESSAGE
Post a Request - Answer a Question
Share a Recipe
Thank You To All Who Contribute
  • Please select one:
  • This message includes a recipe that I have not made Recipe: will appear as the first word of the title
  • This message includes a recipe that I have made Recipe (tried): will appear as the first words of the title
  • This message is a question or a request for a recipe ISO: (In Search of) will appear as the first words of the title
  • This message is to thank the person(s) that answered my request Thank You will appear as the first words of the title
  • No Prefix